Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich Cookies
Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop
95 In Stock
Peanut Butter and Jelly on sliced bread is old news! Satisfy that PB&J craving with Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich Cookies. Two soft peanut butter cookies are sandwiched around organic all-natural strawberry preserves for the perfect after-school or after-work treat.
Related Products
Signature Chocolate Chip Cookies
The Signature Chocolate Chip Cookie is crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, with specks of vanilla throughout, big chunks of chocolate in ev...
Cookie of the Month Club
**When Signing Up, Please Inform us of any Allergens (Peanut, Tree Nut or Gluten).  About Our Cookie of the Month Club Little Red Kitchen Bake Sho...
Ginger Molasses Cookies
Ginger Molasses cookies are back in stock for the winter season! Â These chewy molasses cookies have a tiny ginger kick, filled with winter spices a...
Holiday Cookie Box
Treat yourself to a sweet surprise this holiday season with this delicious Holiday Cookie Box! Featuring classic chocolate chip, festive double cho...
Create your own Cookie Box
 You asked and we listened - create your own cookie boxes are here! Mix and match from any of our standard cookies or choose one of our seasonal f...
Signature Cookie Gift Box
Our most popular cookies are now featured our Signature Cookie Gift Boxes. Choose from Lemon Sugar and Amaretti each in a 12 ounce gift box contai...
Peanut Butter Cookies
Soft and chewy peanut butter cookies baked with all-natural organic peanut butter and brown sugar will make the peanut butter lover incredibly happy.
Cookie of the Month Club - 3 Months
**When Signing Up, Please Inform us of any Allergens (Peanut, Tree Nut or Gluten). About Our Cookie of the Month Club Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop ...
S'mores Cookies
Ooey, gooey, marshmallowy and chocolatey! Don't have a fire to roast up your s'mores? No problem! Get your fix this summer with these irresistible ...
Lemon Sugar Cookies
Brighten your day with a package of sparkling chewy lemon sugar cookies! Â We can customize the order to any color that you like!
Brookies
What happens when a chocolate chip cookie meets a brownie? The Brookie is born! At first it may look like a regular chocolate chip cookie but once...
Amaretti Cookies
These Italian inspired Amaretti cookies are naturally and dairy gluten-free with a rich almond flavor and light chewy texture similar to a macaron....
Triple Chocolate Cookies
Triple Chocolate Chip cookies or rather Triple Choc-o-lot because they contain that much chocolate, these guys are cookies in brownie form. Â This c...
Cookie of the Month Club - 6 Months
**When Signing Up, Please Inform us of any Allergens (Peanut, Tree Nut or Gluten). About Our Cookie of the Month Club Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop ...
Fall Harvest Cookie Box
Celebrate the flavors of autumn with our Fall Harvest Cookie Box. This sampler box will be around only for a limited time! This limited edition bo...
Caramel Apple Oatmeal Cookies
Ooey, gooey, sticky and chewy! Caramel Apple Oatmeal Cookies have a little bit of everything in this Autumnal flavored treat! These cookies are on...
Chocolate Lovers Gift Box
Our Valentine's Day cookie box is back! Treat the chocolate lover in your life to the Chocolate Lovers Cookie Gift Box featuring Signature Chocolat...
Double Chocolate Peppermint Cookies
Get into the holiday spirit with these double chocolate peppermint cookies. Packed with white chocolate chunks, dark cocoa powder and a touch of pe...
DIY Cookie Kits
Love to bake but not the hassle? Let us help you out with our DIY Cookie Kits! Each kit comes with pre-measured dry ingredients that you need plus ...
Brown Sugar Pumpkin Cookies
Soft and tender brown sugar pumpkin cookies are loaded with autumnal spices that are a taste of fall in each and every bite. Â We use all-natural, o...
Cookie of the Month Club - 12 Months
**When Signing Up, Please Inform us of any Allergens (Peanut, Tree Nut or Gluten). About Our Cookie of the Month Club Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop ...
Sprinkle Cookies
Brighten up your day with our bakery style sprinkle cookies using dye-free sprinkles!  Certified kosher by MK Kosher.Â
Holiday Shortbread Gift Box
 New for the holiday season! Miniature shortbread gift box featuring 4 delightful shortbread cookie flavors! This box contains bite sized shortbre...
Shortbread and Hot Chocolate Gift Set
 This holiday season we're offering a limited edition shortbread and hot chocolate gift set. This gift set contains a tin of a dozen mini peppermi...