Peanut Butter Cookies
Little Red Kitchen Bake Shop
37 In Stock
Soft and chewy peanut butter cookies baked with all-natural organic peanut butter and brown sugar will make the peanut butter lover incredibly happy.
Related Products
Create your own Cookie Box
 You asked and we listened - create your own cookie boxes are here! Mix and match from any of our standard cookies or choose one of our seasonal f...
Signature Chocolate Chip Cookies
The Signature Chocolate Chip Cookie is crispy on the outside, chewy on the inside, with specks of vanilla throughout, big chunks of chocolate in ev...
Cookie of the Month Club
**When Signing Up, Please Inform us of any Allergens (Peanut, Tree Nut or Gluten).  Shipping notice - new subscriptions are shipped within a few ...
Molasses Spice Cookies
Our Molasses Spice Cookies have won the gold sofi award and product of the year-food from the Specialty Food Association for 2024! Soft and chewy m...
Signature Cookie Gift Box
Our most popular cookies are now featured our Signature Cookie Gift Boxes. Choose from Lemon Sugar and Amaretti each in a 12 ounce gift box contai...
Brookies
What happens when a chocolate chip cookie meets a brownie? The Brookie is born! At first it may look like a regular chocolate chip cookie but once...
Cookie of the Month Club - 3 Months
**When Signing Up, Please Inform us of any Allergens (Peanut, Tree Nut or Gluten). Shipping notice - new subscriptions are shipped within a few da...
S'mores Cookies
Ooey, gooey, marshmallowy and chocolatey! Don't have a fire to roast up your s'mores? No problem! Get your fix this summer with these irresistible ...
Cookie of the Month Club - 6 Months
**When Signing Up, Please Inform us of any Allergens (Peanut, Tree Nut or Gluten). Shipping notice - new subscriptions are shipped within a few da...
Amaretti Cookies
These Italian inspired Amaretti cookies are naturally and dairy gluten-free with a rich almond flavor and light chewy texture similar to a macaron....
Lemon Sugar Cookies
Brighten your day with a package of sparkling chewy lemon sugar cookies! Â We can customize the order to any color that you like!
Giant Cookie Collection
 Giant Cookies are here for a limited time! Total amount for the gift set is $36 for 6 cookies. This gift set includes 6 - SIX OUNCE giant cookie...
Triple Chocolate Cookies
Triple Chocolate Chip cookies or rather Triple Choc-o-lot because they contain that much chocolate, these guys are cookies in brownie form. Â This c...
Cookie Bouquets
We're bringing our cookie bouquets back for Mother's Day. When you can't decide between flowers or cookies, choose both with our cookie bouquets! W...
Chocolate Lovers Gift Box
Our Valentine's Day cookie box is back! Treat the chocolate lover in your life to the Chocolate Lovers Cookie Gift Box featuring Signature Chocolat...
Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich Cookies
Peanut Butter and Jelly on sliced bread is old news! Satisfy that PB&J craving with Peanut Butter & Jelly Sandwich Cookies. Two soft peanut...
Spring Cookie Box
Get into the spring time spirit with our limited edition Spring Cookie Box! The perfection addition to your Easter Basket, Mother's Day brunch spre...
Summer Cookie Box
Our Summer Cookie Box is back for the season!  This box is a taste of sunshine and berries in each bite! This box includes half a dozen of our ne...
DIY Cookie Kits
Love to bake but not the hassle? Let us help you out with our DIY Cookie Kits! Each kit comes with pre-measured dry ingredients that you need plus ...
Sprinkle Cookies
Brighten up your day with our bakery style sprinkle cookies using dye-free sprinkles!  Certified kosher by MK Kosher.Â
Cookie of the Month Club - 12 Months
**When Signing Up, Please Inform us of any Allergens (Peanut, Tree Nut or Gluten).  Shipping notice - new subscriptions are shipped within a few ...
Award Winning Cookie Box
 Bake some noise, because our Molasses Spice Cookies have just been crowned 2024 Product of the Year-Food by the Specialty Food Association! Our c...
Blueberries and Cream Cookies
Blueberries and Cream Cookies are loaded up with dried blueberries, oats and Belgian white chocolate for a chewy taste of summer.
Strawberry Crinkle Cookies
Who needs a strawberry patch when you can munch on these our seasonal summer cookie? Indulge in the sweet, juicy flavor of strawberry cookies with ...